Struggle for Recognition: A Case Study of Balochistan, Pakistan
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21637757Anahtar Kelimeler:
Baloch insurgency, recognition, justice, moral injury, redistributionÖzet
This study examines the Baloch insurgency in Pakistan through the intersecting lenses of recognition, justice, and the shift from realist to constructivist approaches. Its purpose is to explain the insurgency beyond conventional security and economic frameworks by showing how structural, cultural, and psychological exclusion shape Baloch grievances. The study draws on Nancy Fraser’s concepts of misrecognition and maldistribution and Axel Honneth’s notion of moral injury to analyze how state policies have denied the Baloch recognition as full citizens with a respected identity. As a critical review article, the paper employs a theory-guided qualitative analysis of purposively selected secondary sources, including peer-reviewed scholarship, policy reports on the 18th Amendment and CPEC, official statistics, and Human Rights Commission of Pakistan reports. The analysis covers the period from 1948 to 2024. The analysis indicates that the insurgency has been driven not only by resource disputes, political marginalization, and uneven development, but also by experiences of invisibility, disrespect, and moral injury associated with the exploitative use of Baloch gas and mineral resources. The results indicate that a narrow focus on security and material distribution is insufficient to explain the conflict’s persistence. These results reframe the conflict as a struggle over both resources and dignity rather than a purely security-centered insurgency. The study concludes that durable peace in Balochistan requires a justice-oriented framework combining redistribution with recognition. It recommends that policymakers address material inequality, political exclusion, identity-based grievances, and demands for dignity and inclusion in order to advance sustainable conflict resolution and long-term peace.
Referanslar
Ahmadzai, P. M. (2025, April 6). Balochistan’s paradox: Rich in resources, poor in development. Modern Diplomacy. https://moderndiplomacy.eu/2025/04/06/balochistans-paradox-rich-in-resources-poor-in-development/
Ahmed, M. (2023). Political economy of elite capture and clientelism in public resource distribution: Theory and evidence from Balochistan, Pakistan. India Quarterly: A Journal of International Affairs, 79(2), 223–243. https://doi.org/10.1177/09749284231165115
Ali, A. (2024). The formation of the Baloch national struggle. Academy of Democratic Modernity. https://democraticmodernity.com/the-formation-of-the-baloch-national-struggle/
Amnesty International. (2020). Pakistan: The disappeared of Balochistan. https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/asa33/3334/2020/en/
Amnesty International. (2024). The true cost of enforced disappearances. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/08/pakistan-end-enforced-disappearances/
Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project (ACLED). (2020). Rising organized political violence in Balochistan: A resurgence of Baloch separatism? https://acleddata.com/report/rising-organized-political-violence-balochistan-resurgence-baloch-separatism
Baloch, B. (2021, November 17). Thousands take part in Gwadar sit-in. Dawn, https://www.dawn.com/news/1658521
Baloch, I. (1987). The problem of “Greater Baluchistan”: A study of Baluch nationalism. Steiner Verlag Wiesbaden.
Baloch, S. B., Baloch, S., & Badini, A. (2025). Good governance for conflict resolution in Balochistan. Annual Methodological Archive Research Review, 3(12), 106–133. https://doi.org/10.63075/yzrk9q12
Breseeg, T. M. (2004). Baloch nationalism: Its origin and development. Royal Book Company.
Bressiani, N. (2011). Redistribuição e reconhecimento: Nancy Fraser entre Jürgen Habermas e Axel Honneth. Caderno CRH, 24(62), 331–352. https://doi.org/10.1590/S0103-49792011000200007
Ejaz, M., & Rehman, A. (2022). Exploration of the foundations of ethnic conflicts in Balochistan: A theoretical perspective. Liberal Arts and Social Sciences International Journal, 6(1), 166–181. https://doi.org/10.47264/IDEA.LASSIJ/6.1.4
Fraser, N. (1995). From redistribution to recognition? Dilemmas of justice in a “postsocialist” age. New Left Review, 212, 68–93. https://doi.org/10.64590/4rl
Fraser, N. (1998). Social justice in the age of identity politics: Redistribution, recognition, and participation. In G. B. Peterson (Ed.), The Tanner lectures on human values (Vol. 19, pp. 1–67). University of Utah Press.
Fraser, N. (2005). Mapping the feminist imagination: From redistribution to recognition to representation. Constellations, 12(3), 295–307. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1351-0487.2005.00418.x
Giles, D. (2020). Rethinking misrecognition and struggles for recognition: Critical theory beyond Honneth. Insert Philosophy.
Gopalan, K. R. (2022). The genesis of Baloch nationalism: Politics and ethnicity in Pakistan, 1947–1977. Asian Affairs: An American Review, 49(3), 169–171. https://doi.org/10.1080/00927678.2022.2110676
Grare, F. (2013). Balochistan: The state versus the nation. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. https://carnegieendowment.org/research/2013/04/balochistan-the-state-versus-the-nation?lang=en
Hani, U., & Ali, S. (2025). The marginalization of Balochistan: Educational and infrastructural disparities amidst conflict. Journal of Indian Studies, 11(1), 47–60.
Hashmi, R. S. (2015). Baloch ethnicity: An analysis of the issue and conflict with state. Journal of the Research Society of Pakistan, 52(1), 57-84.
Hassan, M., & Jan, A. (2024). Historical analysis of Baloch ethnic identity formation in Baluchistan. The Dialogue, 19(3), 47–57.
Heidegren, C. G. (2002). Anthropology, social theory, and politics: Axel Honneth’s theory of recognition. Inquiry, 45(4), 433–446. https://doi.org/10.1080/002017402320947531
Honneth, A. (1995). The struggle for recognition: The moral grammar of social conflicts. MIT Press.
Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP). (2022, February 17). HRCP sounds alarm over enforced disappearances. https://hrcp-web.org/hrcpweb/hrcp-sounds-alarm-over-enforced-disappearances/
Janusz, A. L.-L. (2022). Why the Belt and Road Initiative furthers the marginalisation of ethnic minorities: A case of Balochistan [Master’s thesis, Leiden University]. Leiden University Student Theses Repository. https://studenttheses.universiteitleiden.nl/nde/fulldisplay?context=L&vid=31UKB_LEU:NDE_Student_Theses&search_scope=Student_Theses&lang=en&docid=alma9940674121102711
Khan, A. (2005). Politics of identity: Ethnic nationalism and the state in Pakistan. Sage Publications. https://archive.org/details/adeel-khan-politics-of-identity-ethnic-nationalism-and-the-state-in-pakistan-sage-publications-2005
Khan, K., & Sherbaz, S. (2025). Political violence as commitment problem: Evidence from Balochistan, Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review, 64(1), 73–95. https://doi.org/10.30541/v64i1pp.73-95
Khan, S. G., Jan, A., & Khan, G. (2025). A study of the causes of political instability in Balochistan after 2010. Journal of Asian Development Studies, 14(1), 812–820. https://doi.org/10.62345/jads.2025.14.1.63
Khan, S., & Laoutides, C. (2024). Trapped between religion and ethnicity: Identity politics against the Baloch in Iran and Pakistan. Dynamics of Asymmetric Conflict, 17(2), 164–184. https://doi.org/10.1080/17467586.2024.2356508
Khoso, S. (2024). Ethnic disloyalty or federal loyalty? Frontiers in Political Science, 6. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpos.2024.1476454
Lovell, T. (2007). (Mis)recognition, social inequality and social justice: Nancy Fraser and Pierre Bourdieu. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203932667
Masomy, M. J. (2025). Balochistan conflict and insecurity: China’s realist approach under CPEC. In P. Pietrzak (Ed.), Geopolitical rivalries and strategic competition across Eurasia (pp. 161–188). IGI Global Scientific Publishing. https://doi.org/10.4018/979-8-3373-5671-6.ch007
McNay, L. (2008). The trouble with recognition: Subjectivity, suffering, and agency. Sociological Theory, 26(3), 271-296. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9558.2008.00329.x
Mihrullah, M., Hatim, M., & Irfan, A. (2025). CPEC in Balochistan: The marginalized, exploited and beneficiaries. The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies, 4(1), 40–58. https://doi.org/10.59075/hn7hwg45
Murtaza, A., & Imroze, L. (2025). Ethnic identity, nationalism and governance in Pakistan. Journal of Asian Development Studies, 14(1), 464–473. https://doi.org/10.62345/jads.2025.14.1.35
Novelli, M., Lopes Cardozo, M. T. A., & Smith, A. (2017). The 4Rs framework: Analyzing education’s contribution to sustainable peacebuilding with social justice in conflict-affected contexts. Journal on Education in Emergencies, 3(1), 14–43.
O’Brien, R. (2025). Forced disappearances in Pakistan: The case of Mahrang Baloch. Amnesty International UK. https://www.amnesty.org.uk/blogs/country-specialists/forced-disappearances-pakistan-case-mahrang-baloch
Panigassi, P. L. (2021). Axel Honneth e Nancy Fraser: Dilemas entre o reconhecimento e a redistribuição. Revista Sem Aspas, 9(2), 231–246. https://doi.org/10.29373/sas.v9i2.14695
Pilapil, R. D. (2013). Disrespect and political resistance: Honneth and the theory of recognition. Thesis Eleven, 114(1), 48–60. https://doi.org/10.1177/0725513612454363
Safdar, Z. K. (2024, September 20). Addressing poverty in Balochistan. Pakistan Today. https://www.pakistantoday.com.pk/2024/09/20/addressing-poverty-in-balochistan/
Samad, Y. (2014). Understanding the insurgency in Balochistan. Commonwealth & Comparative Politics, 52(2), 293–320. https://doi.org/10.1080/14662043.2014.894280
Shah, S. A., & Jules, T. D. (2025). Higher education in crisis – From dictatorship to neoliberalism: Peacebuilding at the University of Balochistan in Pakistan. Globalisation, Societies and Education. https://doi.org/10.1080/14767724.2025.2549722
Talpur, M. M. A. (2023). How Pakistan systematically tried to wipe out the Baloch identity. Dissent Today. https://dissenttoday.net/opinion/how-pakistan-systematically-tried-to-wipe-out-the-baloch-identity/
The Balochistan Post. (2024, October 31). The broken promises of the Pakistani state to Balochistan. https://thebalochistanpost.net/2024/10/the-broken-promises-of-the-pakistani-state-to-balochistan/
Ullah, N., & Akhtar, N. (2024). Changing dynamics of Baloch insurgency: Implications for national stability and security. Journal of Asian Development Studies, 13(2), 1328–1344. https://doi.org/10.62345/jads.2024.13.2.106
van den Brink, B. (2010). The political theory of recognition: A critical introduction, by Simon Thompson [Review of the book The political theory of recognition: A critical introduction, by S. Thompson]. European Journal of Philosophy, 18(4), 600–604. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0378.2010.00442.x
Wani, S. A. (2023). Development and militarization in Balochistan, Pakistan. Strategic Analysis, 47(5), 478–494. https://doi.org/10.1080/09700161.2023.2288993
İndir
Yayınlanmış
Nasıl Atıf Yapılır
Sayı
Bölüm
Lisans
Telif Hakkı (c) 2026 Muniba Ali, Onur Yamaner
Bu çalışma Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License ile lisanslanmıştır.
